My char is Minxy on dreadmaul

I have a score of 3270

My guildy is Seraphblade on dreadmaul

he has a score of 3276

I have two pieces of 277 two pieces of 251 and the rest 264

He has two pieces of 277 two pieces of 245 and the rest 264

We are both correctly gemmed and enchanted. How does this work?

we both have the 277 rep ring. I have a heroic 277 helm and he has a heroic 277 2h dk tanking mace. But we dont have a dk tank so he uses for fury.

Just wondering how this system works and who decides the value of things.