+6 stats is superior to 150 health for a druid (fully raid buffed ofc)
Yes I lose HP by switch back to those items (I keep most of em in the bank just in case I wanna switch stuff about).
But switching back to those (and using a pot to buff health 250/500) overall lowered my hp, dodge, crit and armour. All the important tanking stuff. in my situation it worked out better.
I reached the point were i thought "which is better, using a pot that gives 250 health or one that gives me +30 res"? That +30 res allowed a fairly large shift in my gear, and for me its worked out for the better.
At the moment Im trying to get the Trinket from HMgt (bloody thing just wont drop for me) and Im gonna start working towards the S3 Head. Once I have those I will be further swapping out my neck & cloak enchant for more appropriate things. but hey, who doesnt need to improve there gear
But. Going back the point I was trying to make. The site needs a capacity to 'judge' if an item is actually an upgrade for the toon based on more that its ilevel.