I have two guild members. One "Followz" has no item under 200 lvl and one at 213. Fully gemmed and chanted. He has 4 raid achievements. Compared to our other lock with the same talent spec who has gear item levels lower. Only one raid achievement isn't fully chanted.
On a compare there is not a single thing Vergauze beats Followz on. Nothing. Same spec and lesser everything else.
Yet Vergauze has a higher rating.