my character Pallyash (US, Eitrigg) wont show up under holy paladins or for healers in general. his score says 4833, so he should be like 43 for overall healers on realm for horde only. but he doesnt chow up anywhere. and when he is in ret, it doesnt either. only tank does.
On the realm and guild tab your character will be always shown in his best scored spec (spec marked with star in the character page). If you want to be able to see your character in holly spec, log off in your protection spec without gear or without few items.