1st, I LOVE this website but have a a question on your trinket rating system:
FYI, referencing as a Pally tank
Rating 128: Brightbrew Charm gives +45 stamina (plus use is for Role play only)
Rating 109: Commander's Badge gives you +45 stamina plus use of fighting dragon pet every 10 minutes
Rating 100: Darkmoon Card: Vengeance gives you +51 stamina and 10% chance when hit to deal x dmg to attacker
Actual for my tanking needs, I prefer the Darkmoon and commanders badge over the drinking brightbrew charm.